Blown To Bits

“Google Violates Its ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Motto”

Wednesday, November 19th, 2008 by Harry Lewis
Each cheap prednisolone in canada meal kit arrives with the ingredients premeasured, so all a generic augmentin person needs to do is follow the cooking instructions. Elahere bentyl sale may not be right for you if you have certain order viagra in us medical conditions or other factors affecting your health. Some experts buy cialis low cost pharmacy warn that people who have had Asherman syndrome should receive artane cheap drug routine sonography to check for the development of endometrial cancer buy cialis once daily before or after menopause. Depression refers to a mood disorder (metacam) tablet involving a persistent feeling of sadness and loss of interest. cheapest cipro The LES is a circle of muscle that acts as gentamicin eye drops for sale a valve between the esophagus and stomach to prevent stomach contents.

Last night a team consisting of myself, Siva Vaidhyanathan (of UVa, author of Copyrights and Copyrwrongs and The Anarchist in the Library), and Randy Picker (of Chicago Law School) debated a team of Esther Dyson (author of Release 2.0), Jeff Jarvis (author of the forthcoming What Would Google Do?), and Jim Harper¬†(director of information policy studies at the Cato Institute). It was fun for everyone, I think. I could have argued either side, but I was recruited for the affirmative. I focused my argument strictly on Google cooperating with the Chinese government by producing a censored version of its search engine, which I rather too dramatically also referred to as an “instrument of thought control” and likened to a “brainwashing serum” that no responsible American pharma company would make for a foreign government. It was an Oxford-style debate; I took it as my job to sway the crowd and win the argument, without lying but perhaps by exaggerating if the other side would let me get away with it. I think several of the other participants took it rather more as an actual religious war.

In the pre-debate poll, the voting was very much against the motion; when the poll was repeated, it was a dead tie, 47%-47%, with 6% undecided. By the debate rules — winner whoever changes the most minds — our team won. Fitting, on the eve of the 40th anniversary of Harvard’s great comeback 29-29 win over Yale in football!

The debate is in the Intelligence Squared series. A bouquet to the sponsors and staff of the series; it’s a great thing to do. Last night’s will be up on Youtube by the end of the week and in an NPR one-hour edited version shortly thereafter.

One Response to ““Google Violates Its ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Motto””

  1. Blown to Bits » Blog Archive » YouTube Videos of the Debate about Google Says:

    […] “Google Violates Its ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Motto” […]