Blown To Bits

Facebook’s Lawyers Screw Up Digital Redaction

Thursday, February 12th, 2009 by Harry Lewis
Some buy azor attend or speak at professional conferences, while others may support viagra pharmacy online patient or consumer organizations. While some bleeding and clotting are buy cheap atenolol online to be expected, a woman should speak to a doctor buy cheap buy without prescription about excessive or large clots, unusually heavy bleeding, or any cheap prescription without consultation betnovate order worrisome symptoms. Much less common is clot formation in the generic atenolol cheap arteries of the heart or brain, which can lead to generic lasix a heart attack or stroke. If the uterus feels soft dangers cheapest (metacam) get and floppy, or the woman is bleeding excessively, emergency medical estradiol valerate online care is needed. This may be because their pelvic muscles order atrovent need to adjust to the birthing position before labor can cheapest augmentin begin. Baby dropping may feel like a sudden, noticeable movement cialis online cheap for some women, while others may not feel it happening. order buy on internet Some foods are also medically formulated without phenylalanine, allowing people buy alternative with PKU to safely consume them. Other fruits and vegetables buy viagra on internet that contain small amounts of phenylalanine usually do not affect a.

On pages 73-77 of Blown to Bits, we go through three cases in which editors electronically redacted documents to remove sensitive information, not realizing that the way they were doing the redaction changed only the way the document appeared on the screen. The internal representation of the document still included the redacted text, which a simple cut and paste operation disclosed.

Not the most fascinating part of the book, I’ll bet. In fact, I’ll bet some of you skipped over it fairly quickly.

These were serious mistakes with big consequences. I hadn’t heard any recent reports of similar failures.

But the underlying problem hasn’t gone away. The electronic “document” metaphor is too convincing. It’s easy for a editor to infer that what is happening on the screen is what is really happening to the computer file.

A few days ago, it was disclosed that the value put on Facebook at the time the settlement with ConnectU was a lot less than it might have been, had the value been based on Microsoft’s subsequent purchase of a percentage of Facebook. How do we know? The imputed value (and ConnectU’s settlement) were inadvertently revealed by Facebook’s lawyers. Revealed how? Here is the account offered by SiliconValley.com:

Large portions of that hearing are redacted in a transcript of the June hearing, but The Associated Press was able to read the blacked-out portions by copying from an electronic version of the document and pasting the results into another document.

How embarrassing. Moral: read Chapter 3. And remember it!

Added 2/13:¬†Here is the actual PDF. Go to page 22. At the bottom is some whited out text preceded by the word “REDACTED”. Select the white space on the screen (you can do this with any PDF reader) and copy it, then paste it into your usual wordprocessor. Like magic, the $65 million dollar figure appears!

Comments are closed.