Blown To Bits

A File With 100 million Facebook Users’ Data

Wednesday, July 28th, 2010 by Harry Lewis
Call aldactone your doctor right away if you have an allergic reaction viagra price to Jesduvroq, as the reaction could become severe. When an order remeron from us organization includes certain drugs in treatment guidelines, this means that atenolol online research has shown the drug to be safe and effective. order petcam (metacam) oral suspension However, doctors may recommend chemotherapy if a person has already buy generic flagyl cost oral received other treatments, such as targeted drugs and immunotherapy. Part atarax sale of their training covers how to examine dead people's bodies purchase cheap cialis low cost consultation and their organs in order to acquire relevant information. If discount cipro you're not sure whether you'll need to get prior authorization generic ampicillin cheap for Mirena, contact your insurance company. People with ASD are atenolol prescription at an increased risk of seizures, so doctors may prescribe viagra prescription anticonvulsant drugs to help manage them. In other words, a buy generic retin-a cost professional doctor may consider prescribing an additional drug shortly after the estradiol buy diagnosis to help prevent one treatment from failing. The Ethics buy 60 in canada Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine have concluded that.

So some clown, sorry, security researcher has done a scan of every Facebook profile his robot could reach and assembled a file of all their public information, and posted it for download. 100 million profiles.

I could have done it. You could have done it. No need to bother, though, because Ron Bowes did it for you.

This is one of those things that is not a technology story. It’s an ontology story, or a spiritual story, or something.

Facebook reports that it’s all public information, public because the users wanted it public. So there is no news here, in their view.
“No private data is available or has been compromised,” as they say. And they are correct technically. Why is it creepier to have your data in a file with 99,999,999 other profiles, on everybody’s laptop, when the same information about you would have turned up in a Facebook query, or a Google search for that matter? Public is public, right?

The aggregation sure makes it feel different. But that is a matter of feelings, and Facebook’s response was written by its legal team. For lawyers, everything is a binary. Things are either black or white. But privacy has lots of grey.

The Telegraph has a good report on it.

2 Responses to “A File With 100 million Facebook Users’ Data”

  1. Maredith Says:

    LOL2….very interesting…hehe

  2. PS Says:

    From a technical and legal standpoint, he did nothing wrong, he simply make already public information available from another channel. Nor did Facebook do anything wrong, they allowed him to crawl their public data like they allow anyone to crawl (be it a regular user, a data-mining researcher, or an evil person).

    There can be several possible consequences as a result of such incidents:

    – If incidents such as this end up raising public awareness about the risks of over-sharing on social networks, then thats great.

    – If as a result of the media bashing, Facebook decides to change its defaults to be more private, then thats even greater.

    – But if as a result of all this, Facebook legal team gets together and makes crawling of their data illegal, and they add strict rate-limits to their servers, then that would be very sad, it would be a big disservice to the research community.

    I hope (as a researcher) that the first two consequences happen, and not the third.